Sample Scenario: Website Redesign and SEO Recovery
A professional services firm launches a beautiful new website — and loses 60% of its organic traffic in six weeks. Here is how a forensic recovery engagement rebuilds what the redesign broke.
The prettiest site their customers could no longer find
The redesign changed every URL without redirects, dropped 40+ ranking pages as “outdated,” and shipped templates that were slow and thin. Google responded predictably: rankings collapsed, leads followed, and nobody on the project could explain why.
This is the most preventable disaster in SEO — and one of the most common engagements we run.
Where things stood
Organic traffic down roughly 60% in six weeks
Every URL changed with no redirect map
Dozens of ranking pages deleted in the redesign
New templates slower than the old site
The strategy
Forensics first, then methodical repair
Recovery is not magic — it is reconstruction. The plan: diff the old site against the new to find every lost URL and page, rebuild the redirect map, restore the content that earned rankings, fix template speed, then resume forward SEO once the bleeding stopped.
The plan
Crawl archive vs. live-site diff of every URL
Complete redirect map, old structure to new
Restoration of deleted ranking content
Template speed and Core Web Vitals repair
Ongoing SEO once recovery stabilized
Work completed
Nine months from triage to new highs
Recovery
300+ redirects mapped and implemented
45 ranking pages restored or rebuilt with intent intact
Schema and internal linking reinstated
Search Console errors worked to zero
Rebuild & growth
Template speed overhaul to green Core Web Vitals
Content refreshed around current search intent
New service pages targeting unclaimed keywords
Monthly recovery reporting against the pre-redesign baseline
Sample results
What success looks like in this scenario
Illustrative metrics shown to demonstrate the reporting format — these will be replaced with verified client results.
Of pre-redesign traffic recovered by month 5 (sample)
0%
Above the old baseline by month 9 (sample)
+0%
More organic leads than before the drop (sample)
+0%
Redirects mapped and implemented (sample)
0+
Lessons learned
What this scenario teaches
Redesigns need SEO supervision
Every redesign is a migration. Treat it like one, or pay for it in traffic.
Redirects are not optional
A complete redirect map is the cheapest insurance in digital marketing — and the most skipped.
Recovery is methodical, not magic
Diff, map, restore, repair — the discipline is boring and it works.
Lost traffic after a redesign or migration?
Request a free recovery audit. We will diagnose exactly what broke — and give you the honest timeline to get it back.